Call us: 631-284-6383 shop@espmetal.com
The Hamptons are known for fine dining and upscale eateries, but that doesn’t mean they don’t know good pizza. Nestled among chic restaurants and swanky bars, you can find pizza that rivals the best New York City has to offer. If you’re looking for a pie in eastern Long Island, don’t miss:
Visit any one of these spots to see how the Hamptons does pizza.
Located in 25 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, Scotto’s Pork Store is a top-rated authentic Italian pork and meat store with a generous pizza menu alongside their meat market offerings. Try their brick oven stuffed pizza, with sausage, pepperoni, mozzarella, spinach, and ricotta. Throwing a party? They also offer catering.
Sam’s Bar and Restaurant has been serving the people of East Hampton since 1947. The restaurant, located at 36 Newtown Lane, East Hampton, offers an extensive list of meat and topping options as well as several gourmet pies. If you’re looking for something a little unique, try their Greek pizza, topped with kalamata olives, feta, garlic, onions, and spinach.
If you’re looking for flavorful pizza, your search is over. Pizzetteria Brunetti, at 103 main street, West Hampton, serves up authentic Neapolitan pizza (including vegan options). The Vongole, their signature pie, is a bold clam pizza with freshly shucked local Long Island clams, garlic and herb butter, and fresh parsley atop a chewy crust.
Whether you’re looking for a casual dining experience or a chic date spot, Uncle Joe’s has you covered. Their restaurant, located at 258 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bay, boasts two dining rooms—one upscale space for fine dining, and one casual spot for relaxing after a day at the beach. Try their white pizza, topped with spinach or broccoli.
Looking to satisfy a late-night pizza craving? World Pie’s kitchen is open until midnight, every night. For a unique twist on a classic, try their smoked pizza—featuring smoked mozzarella, tomato, and basil. You can find them at 2402 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton.
La Parmigiana is home to generous portions, a fun, unpretentious atmosphere, and great pizza. Visit them at 48 NY-27A, Southampton, and try their broccoli rabe pizza, topped with broccoli rabe, sweet Italian sausage, garlic, and fresh, homemade mozzarella. Avoiding gluten? No worries—gluten-free options are available.
No matter what you want on your pizza—from baked ziti to tacos—American Pie can make it delicious. You can find them at 2044 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton, open seven days a week. Try their Philly cheese steak pizza, with thinly sliced steak, peppers, onions, and a blend of provolone and mozzarella.
An unassuming spot attached to a Dunkin’ Donuts, P&G Pizza and Deli is a hidden gem with friendly staff, quick service, and great, thin-crust pizza. It’s a great little on-the-go pizzeria for dropping in to pick up lunch or dinner. Stop by their location at 20 Country Road 39, Southampton, and give their chicken bacon ranch pie a try.
Café Crust is a spot for Neapolitan style wood-fired pizza. They have a list of unique twists on classic pies, like their white hot pizza—a white pizza featuring the fresh mozzarella, ricotta, peccorino romano, and garlic you’d expect, with the addition of jalapeno peppers to give it some kick. Find them at 850 Country Road 39, Southampton.
If you’re after great pizza to go, look no further than Cappelletti at 3284 Noyac Road, in Sag Harbor. Even with an extensive menu, they manage to prepare all of their food to perfection, including dishes made with seasonal local ingredients. All of their ingredients are fresh, right down to the homemade meatballs. Put together your favorite flavor combinations from their generous list of specialty toppings.
No matter whether you’re craving fine Italian food and a posh atmosphere, or just a good, simple plain cheese slice, there’s great food to be had at the east end of Long Island. Visit any one of these spots to see how the Hamptons does pizza.
